Soil Association withdraws organic certification from Scottish salmon farms

The Soil Association has ended organic certification for British salmon farms after a two-year review citing persistent welfare failures. The decision highlights ongoing concerns about aquaculture standards and could pressure the industry to improve practices.

The Soil Association has withdrawn organic certification from Scottish salmon farms after a two-year review found welfare and environmental outcomes did not meet its standards. The decision ends more than 20 years of certification for the sector. The review The Soil Association is the UK's largest organic certification body. It warned last year that it would withdraw certification if the salmon farming industry did not make "meaningful progress." Helen Browning, the charity's chief executive, said progress had been "negligible" despite more than 20 years' work in the area. She said: "While our standards ensure lower stocking rates and prohibit the most damaging chemical treatments, the evidence suggests that welfare and environmental outcomes are not sufficient for us to continue." Browning said the group originally backed salmon farming in the hope that aquaculture could develop in line with organic principles, with a richer marine environment and limited harm to other species. The industry response Salmon Scotland said the removal of the Soil Association logo does not mean the loss of government organic certification. A spokesperson told the Independent: "We have been assured by the UK Government that our farms will continue to be assessed against organic standards with no loss of certification. Consumers can therefore continue to buy Scottish organic salmon with confidence." Salmon Scotland said farms will continue to be assessed against official standards. It said the sector has invested more than £1 billion in fish health, environmental performance and technology, and maintains that survival rates are high and sea lice levels remain on a long-term downward trend. Traders Union reported that the sector is worth about £1 billion a year in Scotland, produces about 205,000 tonnes a year and employs 2,500 people. It is dominated by Mowi, Bakkafrost, Scottish Sea Farms and Cooke Aquaculture Scotland, and has grown from a small Scottish industry in the 1970s. Salmon remains a leading fish choice for British households. Deaths and campaigns The sources give different figures for salmon deaths. Traders Union reported that 17.4 million salmon died before harvest on farms in 2023, and that mortality and welfare outcomes at organic sites were not significantly better than at conventional farms. In February, Animal Equality said Scottish salmon farms recorded 35 million unexpected fish deaths over three years, during which farms received just two unannounced inspections, which it called "embarrassingly poor" oversight. WildFish says salmon farming conflicts with organic principles because of chemical treatments for sea lice, waste and pollution, high mortality rates and continued reliance on wild fish in feed. Traders Union reported that some producers in Europe are now also using poultry byproducts as a lower-cost alternative. It also reported that wild salmon numbers off British shores have fallen by more than 70% over recent decades. In October, Project Slingshot released a documentary titled Gaslit: The Hidden Truth About Salmon Farming in the UK. The film features Chris Packham, Animal Equality's Abigail Penny, journalist and author George Monbiot, and industry experts. It covers the prevalence of diseases and parasites, the use of toxic chemicals such as formaldehyde, and the use of astaxanthin to dye salmon pink. Project Slingshot said: "Don't buy it. We only get what the lice don't eat. Scottish salmon are crammed into cages, eaten alive by sea lice and drenched in toxic chemicals. Even the pink comes off a colour chart."

Read source: Plant Based News